Skip to main content Skip to site footer
Club News

Dyche Puts Penalty Awards On The Spot

2 February 2019

Sean Dyche cited what he hopes is a watershed moment in the awarding of penalties after a day of drama at Turf Moor.

The Burnley manager was perplexed by the decision not to award a spot kick in the first half for a clear foul by Saints goalkeepers Alex McCarthy on Ashley Barnes.
Barnes, who was booked for simulation, then did fire home Burnley’s first penalty in 68 Premier League games with virtually the last kick of the game to cancel out Nathen Redmond’s opener and earn a dramatic point.
But it was the controversy of the first half incident that left Dyche asking the authorities to take a fresh view on penalty decisions.
He said: “I have absolutely no idea, whatsoever, why that penalty wasn’t awarded. I’ll just reiterate that when players fall naturally, I don’t think they are getting penalties.
“I think I’ve been honest enough to speak about that this season, when results have gone against us, such as when Harry Kane should have had one and West Ham should have been awarded one, and I just don’t know where the game is going. 
“Dives get given as penalties and real falls are not getting given and just because Ashley hasn’t thrown his arms in the air and rolled around 10 times, he gets nothing.
“The keeper comes out trying to do his job. the centre forward gets there first and toes it past him, and the keeper brings him down.  It is impossible, in my opinion, that that is not a penalty and I just don’t understand it.
“I hope somewhere down the line there is a watershed moment - and maybe today was that day, where the PGMOL, the Premier League and all the other governing bodies involved look at it and say ‘woah, wait a minute, where are we going?’”
Dyche added: “I always differentiate between gamesmanship and clever play. That has always been around, but I am on about blatant diving.
“Today was, in my opinion a blatant penalty that didn’t get given and, alarmingly, I later found out he (Barnes) was booked for simulation. 
“I cannot believe he gets booked after all I speak about in the Premier League, with players falling everywhere and never getting any punishment, I really can’t.
“What I am worried about for the game – and the bigger picture - is that referees are now giving the dives. 
“I have no clue anymore because that is completely confusing and I hope it’s confusing enough for fans to go ‘hold on, we’ve all had enough of this’. 
“I am probably the most outspoken one on this, and I understand that, but that first penalty today is precisely why I am outspoken.
“To add to that, in theory, because Ashley has gone mad at the decision, he could have been sent off – and that would have been ridiculous. 
“I just hope today was enough for people to say let’s have a look at this because it has to change. Will it? I don’t know.”
The Clarets were left with an uphill task after Redmond fired the Saints ahead in the 55th minute.
But after repeatedly knocking on the door – and following three substitutions, including a debut for Perter Crouch - a late hand ball by Jack Stephens while challenging Crouch in the area, led to Barnes coolly keeping his nerve to earn a point.
“I must mention the mentality of Ashley, to remain calm and focused,” added Dyche.
“To have been not given that penalty and then being booked for simulation is incredible. 
“So to then get a last minute penalty after seeing so many chances stay out, and slot it home, was fantastic for him and I thought we deserved more than a draw today.
“We kept knocking on the door and had some golden chances. 
“We’ve had some hard knocks, recently, that have cost us and we would all have gone home very aggrieved had that cost us. 
“Tomorrow I’ll look at this result differently and think we should have won and had two penalties. 
“But our mentality to see through all that was absolutely superb and I commented on that to the lads at the end. 
“That relentlessness is flying back into the squad and everyone has seen that drive and will to win.
“In some ways, it’s nice to be aggrieved and scratching our head that we haven’t got more.
“I’ll take the points, but it shows that we are not settling for less. We kept going and I was super pleased with that.”

Advertisement block